 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
Chinook Entrepreneur Challenge Page 11
1
2-3
4-5
6-7
8-9
10
Management
No notable
experience
and/or abilities
Little notable
experience
and/or abilities
One team
member with
notable
experience
Several team
members with
notable
experience but
all major areas
not covered
Team covers all
major areas
with notable
experience
and/or abilities
Team covers all
major areas
with notable
experience
and/or abilities
and has a high
profile person
for the business
Implementation
Plan
Not addressed
Unrealistic and
incomplete
planning
Not very
realistic with
significant gaps
Fairly realistic
but planning
incomplete
Realistic and
thorough
planning
Highly realistic
and thorough
planning
Financial
Planning
Critical
assumptions
not presented
Planning and
expected return
based on
unrealistic
assumptions
Planning and
expected return
based on
somewhat
realistic
assumptions
Planning and
expected return
based on
realistic
assumptions but
return not
attractive
Planning and
expected return
based on
realistic
assumptions
and return is
attractive
Planning and
expected return
based on
realistic
assumptions
and return is
highly attractive
Financial
Statements
Financial
statements are
not present
Financial
statements are
present but
contain serious
errors and are
not realistic
Financial
statements are
present, contain
some errors and
are somewhat
realistic
All financial
statements are
accurate but not
realistic
All financial
statements are
accurate and
realistic but may
not reflect the
sustainability of
the business
All financial
statements
accurately and
realistically
reflect the
sustainability of
the business
Risk and Risk
Management
No presentation
of opportunities
and risks and
their effects.
Countermeasur
e missing
Incomplete
presentation of
opportunities
and risks and
their effects.
Countermeasur
e addressed but
incorrect
Sufficient
presentation or
opportunities
and risk and
their effects.
Counter-
measure
correct, but not
adequate
Satisfactory
presentation of
opportunities
and their risks.
Adequate
countermeasure
Good
presentation of
opportunities
and risk and
their effects;
effective
countermeasure
Outstanding
presentation of
opportunities
and risk and
their effects;
innovative and
effective
countermeasure
1-10
11-20
21-30
31-40
41-50
51-60
Overall Business Plan and Plan Fundability: Note scoring change (out of 60)
Opportunity
(Note Scoring
Change. Out of
60)
On the whole,
little point in
pursuing the
business
concept; has
little potential,
the planning is
not well
structured, and
the
presentation
careless
Contains
several
interesting
aspects, but in
its present form,
the overall
concept is not
very persuasive
Contains a
number of
interesting
elements
possibly worth
pursuing, but
overall the
concept has
clear
weaknesses in
potential,
planning, or
presentation
On the whole,
interesting and
possibly worth
pursuing, but
planning and
presentation
have definite
weaknesses
On the whole,
attractive and
worth pursuing;
a business
concept with
great potential,
potentially
sustainable,
contributes to
economy, and a
convincing
presentation
On the whole,
highly attractive
and persuasive
in all main
aspects; a
business
concept with
great potential,
easily
sustainable;
contributes to
economy; an
inspiring
presentation
VIII
Judging Process (Process may be subject to change by the Organizing
Committee)
Phase I
Screening Team divides the plans among the members and reviews for basic content and
believability, professionalism, total plan length, correct number of plans, signed Participants
Agreements, and other key deliverables as outlined on the website.
Plans not containing ALL of the required elements are eliminated from the Challenge.
|
 |
|